Okay, so I also love Glee, and one of my all-time favorite Buffy episodes is Once More with Feeling. I thought, hey, Supernatural, the musical. So I pared down the series to bare bones and tried to find songs for the turning points.
Disclaimer: Some of the songs I picked JUST for the title, not the lyrics.
Dean comes to get Sam to help him find his dad.
Jessica is killed when Sam returns, causing Sam to return to the hunting life.
Song: Highway to Hell
The boys hunt all manner of beasties.
Song: Life is a Highway
Sam begins to learn he has psychic powers, which he hides from Dean.
Song: Am I a Demon by Danzig
Dean finds out, and believes him.
Song: He Ain’t Heavy, He’s My Brother
They find out there are other kids like him, that lost their mother the same way.
Their quest takes them to their childhood home, restored and haunted by something evil—and their mother.
Song: Can’t Find My Way Home by Blind Faith
They are reunited with their dad.
Song: Reunited (I couldn’t resist)
Their dad is kidnapped and possessed and tries to kill them.
Instead of killing Daddy, Sam shoots him in the leg, releasing the demon.
Angry Daddy, beat-up Dean and Sam drive off, only to be t-boned by a truck.
Dean is dying.
Song: Knocking on Heaven’s Door
Daddy makes a deal to save him, and dies.
Song: Had a Dad by Jane’s Addiction
Dean is consumed with guilt, only to be made better when he goes back on the hunt.
They find more psychic children, and Sam goes off on his own, where he’s hunted down by Gordon.
Sam is kidnapped by the YED and forced to fight against the other psychic children for the dubious honor of leading Azazel’s army.
Song: Nice to be Dead by Iggy Pop
Dean makes a deal to bring Sam back.
Song: I Can’t Live by Badfinger (I know….I tried to find something that WASN’T about love)
Dean kills the YED after the gates of hell have been opened.
Song: Ego Tripping at the Gates of Hell by Flaming Lips
Sam and Dean are at odds with the rest of the hunting community because they allowed the gates of hell to be opened and a bunch of demons are running around.
Ruby, a witch-turned-demon, comes to help them, though they don’t trust her.
Song: Witchy Woman
Dean is dealing with the fact that he has one year to live and can’t do anything about it or Sam dies.
Song: Live Like You Were Dying by Tim McGraw
Sam has to watch Dean die over and over in a place called Mystery Spot, to show him how helpless he is.
The boys encounter an old nemesis, Agent Hendrickson, who arrests them.
Song: In the Jailhouse Now
Sam reveals that Ruby told him a demon named Lilith has been looking for him. Lilith comes to the jail after Dean and Sam leave and levels it, killing all inside.
Then Lilith comes for Dean and unleashes the hellhounds. Dean dies.
Song: Fade to Black by Metallica
Dean crawls his way out of the grave.
Song: Ain’t No Grave (Gonna Hold This Body Down) by Johnny Cash
He meets an angel named Castiel.
Song: Send Me an Angel by Real Life
The brothers are needed to help stop Lilith from breaking the 66 seals needed to set Lucifer free.
They later learn Dean broke the first seal by torturing souls in hell.
Song: Straight to Hell by The Clash
Sam has learned, while Dean is gone, that he can be more powerful with his psychic powers when he drinks demon blood. He’s become addicted.
Song: Dirty Little Secret by All American Rejects
The brothers fight violently when Sam tells Dean he’s the better hunter, that Dean is too weak, and Dean is pissed because Sam is still in touch with Ruby.
The brothers discover someone is writing their life story, and he’s a prophet named Chuck.
Song: The Prophets Song by Queen
Dean discovers Sam has a demon blood addiction.
Song: Lay It on the Line
Ruby tricks Sam into killing Lilith, which is the final seal, and Lucifer rises.
Song: Apocalypse Please by Muse
The boys are in the middle of a battle between Lucifer and the angels.
Song: Everybody Wants to Rule the World by Tears for Fears
Lucifer claims Sam is his vessel, and Sam refuses.
Song: Devil’s Plaything by Danzig
The archangel Michael wants Dean as his vessel, that it’s destiny, and Dean refuses.
They look for answers in God, only to learn that God doesn’t think it’s his problem.
Song: God and Satan by Biffy Clyro